My boyfriend and I had our anniversary dinner here and it is by far the best restaurant we have ever been to. From checking in for our reservation, to the service and food, everything was perfect. We started with the BBQ shrimp off of the specials menu which was beautifully done and had a small kick to it which I absolutely loved. When our entrees came out, we were blown away. I had the beef medallions on the specials menu and my boyfriend had the 8oz grilled tenderloin with the onion and Gorgonzola topping. The food is absolutely to die for. I once was a hater for bleu cheese, but I now am a fan because of that cream sauce. My beef medallions were cooked at a perfect medium rare and I could not get enough of the gnocchi and mushroom sauce. I’ve never experienced anything to this caliber on my palette. Not only was the food amazing, but the service was exceptional as well. Emily and her trainee (I’m so sorry to have forgotten her name) were perfect and made great recommendations on beers. Thank you so much for the wonderful anniversary dessert. That was truly sweet for our special day. We will definitely be back again.
Our second time since last August. Food was delicious. Had the BBQ shrimp appetizer, tenderloin medallions with gnocchi and veggies. Our server, Scott, was amazing and attentive. One of our new go-to places when vising St Augustine. We'll be back!
Amazingly delicious and well executed food. One of the best overall meals I've ever had, and that's saying something. I'm a foodie and have eaten at MANY excellent restaurants. The bread was fragrant, fresh and soft, served with an unfiltered olive oil and baked whole garlic, a wonderful combination. The lobster gnocchi app was small but perfect and incredibly flavorful. The shrimp and scallops were just caught fresh and so well done. The purple rice and sauce were a perfect complement. My son loved his burrata app and lamb Nothing could have been any better.
My wife and I had a wonderful experience here. It was reasonably priced and the staff were delightful. It's location is perfect with only a minute walk from St George St. So visiting the many taverns, restaurants and shops will easy. There're are many other B&B's around town but Carriage Way is certainly takes the cake for being the best.
WOW!!! The food here is amazing!!! The flavors are bold and complex. The pairings are interesting and addictive. It’s a small quaint restaurant; quite endearing. Because it’s small, it only seats a few so I highly recommend reservations. Trust me, it’s worth it... I had the lamb which was cooked perfectly. Paired with a bottle of Elouan (Pinot), the only thing missing from this heaven were angels. Wait... there was one, Meghan (the manager) was the best. She was funny and personable with service that was second to none. I really enjoyed the experience and will definitely return very soon.